With more than 20,000 reviews on Amazon, it’s safe to say that the Wonderskin Lip Stain has gone as viral as a lip tint can possible go. The liquid tint comes in more than 15 shades, so there’s something for every skin tone. It’s also smudge-proof, transfer-proof, and eating-proof. But the real selling point is the application process: Once you’ve put it on, you let it dry for about 15 to 30 seconds. Then you wipe it off with a damp towel or tissue. The result, according to fans? Naturally tinted and plumper lips.
But does it live up to the hype? In our first edition of 5 People Try, five Glamour editors put it to the test. Keep reading for a step-by-step review and our honest thoughts.
The Product: Wonderskin Lip Stain
Shade: Hush
I tried the shade Hush, labeled as a neutral brown, but on me, it leaned a little more reddish, as if I’d just eaten a bowl of strawberries. Not quite the deep, moody brown I was hoping for. To be honest, I was a little underwhelmed by the color payoff. I’m someone who loves a strong outer lip, a darker outline to give definition and shape. That’s where I see a stain really shining, as a long-wear base or liner. But Hush applied more like a full-lip flush and didn’t give me the contour or contrast I was looking for. I could see it working better if I used two different shades, but one alone didn’t do the trick.
I will say the formula wears fine. Once it’s on, it’s on, but not quite all-day on. And the water-activated version felt more hassle than helpful. The peel-off version makes more sense, especially for us girlies on the go. And definitely follow up with a lip oil; your lips will need it. Is it game-changing? Not quite. But it has potential, with a few tweaks.
Rating: 6/10
Shade: XOXO
I heard about Wonderskin lip stains when they originally blew up on TikTok but only recently did I give them a try. I was actually impressed by the color payoff compared to other products. The XOXO in particular gave me a bright shade of pink that paired well with my lip gloss. It lasted my entire workday, and I didn’t feel the need to reapply so many times. I think it’s great for special events when you don’t want to have to constantly check your pout. You do have to make sure to apply a hydrating lip balm, because the formula can be a little drying. As a shopping editor, I’ve tried my fair share of lip products, and this one is going on top of my list.
Rating: 8.5/10
Shade: Hush
Okay, Wonderskin Lip Tint is kind of a game changer. It’s gym-proof, meal-proof, and yes... even make-out-proof. Once it sets, it does not budge. I will say, it can feel a little dry on the lips, but I just layer a gloss on top and it looks amazing. My go-to shades are Whimsical when I want something bold and XOXO for an everyday flush. If you’re tired of reapplying lipstick all day, this is totally worth trying.
Rating: 8/10
Shade: Hush
The Wonderskin Lip Stain is a very interesting product to wear. I wore the color Hush, a medium-brown tint. It goes on wet and blue, but don’t let that scare you away. Once you leave it to dry for a few seconds and wipe it off, the color is true to match. I really liked the color payoff because it was more pigmented than I thought, which is a big plus. It does feel pretty dry on application, so I was eager to put on lip balm afterward. The product claims to be “smudge-proof, transfer-proof, water-resistant,” all of which I agree with. If you’re looking for a stain under a gloss, this is the perfect product for you!
Rating: 7/10
Shade: Whimsical
I was pleasantly surprised by this lip stain. As someone with very sensitive lips, I was afraid it would irritate my skin, but it gave me no reaction. It’s a little messy to apply, but the results are worth it—my lips had a perfect rosy color that looked very similar to my natural lip color, just enhanced. After that, all I needed to do was apply liner and gloss. Pro tip: Apply pre-makeup, so you don’t mess up your foundation while wiping the stain off.
